Best New Courses of 2025: Thousands of ratings from our experts determined the latest winners
Halfway through a decade of post-Covid golf prosperity, the verdict on 2025 is in: Golf design in the United States is strong and getting stronger.
Judging by the courses that opened this year, developers and architects continue to seek out pieces of land with strong aura, knowing that the innate character of the site is more important than convenience of location. Salvaging also remains a viable path as underperforming and defunct properties are being repurposed with fresh designs set atop the old bones. There’s also an uptick in residential developments, a segment of the industry that all but died in 2008. More investment is being made in affordable and municipal public golf, and on the other end of the spectrum, elite, historic private clubs keep spending tens of millions of dollars to upgrade their turf, infrastructure and architecture, often as part of a return to some originalist version of their courses.
To conduct our annual awards for Best New Private and Public, Best Renovation and Best Transformation, Golf Digest’s course-ranking panelists visited 47 candidates across the U.S. As good as this year was, the state of golf for 2026 is shaping up to be even busier.
Additional write-ups and photos on every candidate can be found on each of the additional pieces of content. Plus, explore each course review page and leave reviews on the courses you've played to have your ratings featured on our pages.
BEST NEW PRIVATE COURSE
Awarded to the best newly developed courses or rebranded new designs using parts of existing courses.
An imaginative short game is needed to play off the tight surrounds at The Fall Line.
Brian Oar
WINNER
THE FALL LINE (EAST)
Mauk, Ga.
6,610 yards, par 70
Architects: Geoff Ogilvy, Mike Cocking & Ashley Mead (OCM)
Brian Oar captured exclusive drone footage of The Fall Line (East) for Golf Digest. You can find one of the drone shots below—and read a complete review of the Best New Private winner here.
SECOND PLACE
BROOMSEDGE GOLF CLUB
Rembert, S.C.
7,501 yards, par 70
Architects: Mike Koprowski, Kyle Franz
Carolina Pines Golf
Carolina Pines Golf
Carolina Pines Golf
Carolina Pines Golf
Carolina Pines Golf
THIRD PLACE
DARMOR CLUB
Columbus, Texas
7,241 yards, par 72
Architects: Doug Wright, Hal Sutton
HONORABLE MENTION
Loraloma Club, Spicewood, Texas, Architect: David McLay Kidd
Mapleton G.C., Sioux Falls, S.D., Scott Hoffman
Richland at Reynolds Lake Oconee, Greensboro, Ga., Tom Fazio
Soleta G.C., Myakka City, Fla., Nick Price
Windsong Farm (North) G.C., Maple Plain, Minn., John Fought
BEST NEW PUBLIC COURSE
Awarded to the best newly developed public courses or rebranded new designs using parts of existing courses.
David McLay Kidd’s second course at Gamble Sands features as much as 70 feet of elevation change.
Jeff Marsh
WINNER
SCARECROW AT GAMBLE SANDS
Brewster, Wash.
6,921 yards, par 71
Architect: David McLay Kidd
Jeff Marsh
Brian Oar
Patrick Koenig
Brian Oar
Brian Oar
Brian Oar
SECOND PLACE
THE KEEP AT MCLEMORE
Rising Fawn, Ga.
7,700 yards, par 72
Architects: Bill Bergin, Rees Jones
Bailey Roubus
Matt Hahn
Jeff Marsh
Matt Hahn
THIRD PLACE
ROOST AT CABOT CITRUS FARMS
Brooksville, Fla.
7,610 yards, par 72
Architects: Kyle Franz, Ran Morrissett, Mike Nuzzo and Rod Whitman
Courtesy of Cabot/Carolina Pines Golf
Courtesy of Cabot/Carolina Pines Golf
Courtesy of Cabot/Carolina Pines Golf
Courtesy of Cabot/Komo Golf
Courtesy of Cabot/Komo Golf
Carolina Pines Golf
Komo Golf
Carolina Pines Golf
HONORABLE MENTION
Aileron G.C., Lake Suzy, Fla., Kipp Schulties
Bella Ridge G.C., Johnstown, Colo., Art Schaupeter
Corica Park G. Cse. (North), Alameda, Calif., Robert Trent Jones II
Old Fort G.C., Murfreesboro, Tenn., Nathan Crace
The Third at Watersound (Fla.) Club, Mark & Davis Love III
BEST TRANSFORMATION
Awarded to previously existing courses that undergo a major remodel beyond mere renovations that can include new holes, a new routing and a new architectural identity. If you blinked, you wouldn’t recognize it.
Tom Doak returned to his first-ever design with a chance to revitalize it.
Andrew Jowett
WINNER
HIGH POINTE GOLF CLUB
Williamsburg, Mich.
6,960 yards, par 71
Architect: Tom Doak
HPGC/Trey Wren
HPGC/Trey Wren
HPGC/Trey Wren
HPGC/Trey Wren
High Pointe qualifies as golf’s feel-good story of the year. This was the first course Tom Doak built beginning in 1986 as a 26-year-old getting his big break. Located outside of Traverse City, Mich., it was and remains the only course at which he personally shaped all 18 greens. In 2008, the daily-fee course closed and a large section of the property, primarily the first nine holes, were sold to become a hops farm with the remaining parts left to nature.
Though sitting fallow and inert, there was enough remaining of High Pointe’s ghostly form to continually tantalize Doak, who still lives in Traverse City. Then, several years ago, Florida-based businessman and entrepreneur Rod Trump became interested in reviving the design after hearing Doak on a podcast express his desire to someday bring it back. The hop-farm land was not available, but Trump was able to eventually secure what remained of the course along with 160 acres to the east of the old routing and asked Doak to round out an updated version of High Pointe.
Explore our complete review here—including bonus photography and ratings from our expert panelists.
SECOND PLACE
THE INTERNATIONAL (PINES)
Bolton, Mass.
7,082 yards, par 71
Architects: Bill Coore, Ben Crenshaw
Ryan Montgomery
Derek Duncan
Ryan Montgomery
Ryan Montgomery
Ryan Montgomery
Ryan Montgomery
Ryan Montgomery
THIRD PLACE
VAQUERO CLUB
Westlake, Texas
7,390 yards, par 71
Architect: Andrew Green
HONORABLE MENTION
Buffalo Dunes G. Cse., Garden City, Kan., Todd Clark & Zach Varty
Karsten G.C., Stillwater, Okla., Andrew Green
The Killearn Club (Camellia), Tallahassee, Fla., Chris Wilczynski
Lakeside C.C., Houston, Jay Blasi
The Pearl at Kalauao, Aiea, Hawaii, David Dale & Kevin Ramsey
Poppy Ridge G. Cse., Livermore, Calif., Jay Blasi
Sharon Heights G. & C.C., Menlo Park, Calif., Todd Eckenrode
Urbana (Ill.) C.C., Drew Rogers
Vineyards C.C. (North), Naples, Fla., Kipp Schulties
Waynesville (N.C.) Inn & G.C., Bobby Weed
Waldorf Astoria G.C., Orlando, Rees Jones
BEST RENOVATION
Awarded to courses that achieve the most significant improvement through the renovation of the architectural features and infrastructure, including work based on historical precedent.
Andrew Green combined Golden Age and Victorian-era themes at Chevy Chase.
Laurence Lambrecht
WINNER
CHEVY CHASE (Md.) CLUB
7,205 yards, par 71
Architect: Andrew Green
LC Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
SECOND PLACE
BALTUSROL GOLF CLUB
Springfield, N.J.
7,000 yards, par 72
Architects: Gil Hanse, Jim Wagner
Evan Schiller
Evan Schiller
Evan Schiller
Evan Schiller
Evan Schiller
Evan Schiller
Evan Schiller
THIRD PLACE
EASTWARD HO!
Chatham, Mass.
6,711 yards, par 72
Architect: Kyle Franz
Laurence Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
Laurence Lambrecht
Derek Duncan
HONORABLE MENTION
Addison Reserve C.C., Delray Beach, Fla., Rees Jones & Steve Weisser
Black Diamond Ranch (Ranch), Lecanto, Fla., Tripp Davis
Callawassie Island (S.C.), in house
Colonial C.C., Fort Worth, Gil Hanse & Jim Wagner
Dunedin (Fla.) G.C., Kris Spence
Evanston G.C., Skokie, Ill., Tyler Rae
The Gasparilla Inn & C., Boca Grande, Fla., Tripp Davis
Lakewood C.C., Westlake, Ohio, Keith Foster
Minneapolis G.C., Jeff Mingay
Pasatiempo G.C., Santa Cruz, Calif., Jim Urbina
PGA West (Stadium), La Quinta, Calif., Tim Liddy
Philadelphia C.C. (Spring Mill), Jim Nagle
Quarry Oaks G.C., Ashland, Neb., John LaFoy
Wedgewood G. & C.C., Powell, Ohio, Bruce Charlton
• • •
Explore Golf Digest's new Course Reviews section where you can submit a star rating and evaluation on all the courses you’ve played. We've collected tens of thousands of reviews from our course-ranking panelists to deliver a premium experience, which includes course rankings, experts' opinions, bonus course photography, videos and much more. Check it out here!